Connect with us

Latest Aproko

Lagos Panel Dismisses Petition Seeking N300m Damages Against Police

A file picture of a police officer displaying the crest of the Nigeria Police Force. PHOTO: Sodiq Adelakun/Channels TV

 

The Lagos State Judicial Panel on Restitution for Victims of SARS Related Abuses has dismissed a petition in search of to implement a N300 million court docket judgment in opposition to the now-disbanded Special Anti-Robbery Squad (SARS).

Justice Rilwan Aikawa of the Federal High Court had awarded the sum as compensation in opposition to the police for the dying of 1 Jimoh Kehinde in 2018.

Two years after the penalty was awarded, one Paschal Bonu introduced the case earlier than the judicial panel because the third petition heard on Tuesday.

But earlier than the petition might be heard by the panel, the police counsel, Joseph Ebosereme, raised a preliminary objection.

He knowledgeable the panel that the matter was already the topic of a civil go well with that had been litigated as much as the Supreme Court, earlier than which it was pending.

“It is an abuse of court process presenting a matter already pending before a competent court. It amounts to double jeopardy in our Constitution,” the policeman stated.

According to him, the petitioner was conscious that the N300 million judgment debt had been reviewed downwards by the Court of Appeal in Lagos.

“The police filed an appeal, judgment was delivered at the Court of Appeal, reducing the amount from N300 million to N30 million,” Ebosereme stated.

He knowledgeable the panel that the police had even approached the Supreme Court to additional problem that call.

READ ALSO: Senate Calls For Removal Of Service Chiefs Following Insurgent Attack On Farmers

The counsel defined that Paschal tried to implement the judgment by acquiring a garnishee order nisi from Justice Aikawa.

“We’ve applied that the garnishee order be set aside too. They are canvassing seriously that they want to garnishee N300 million and then come back and garnishee N30 million.

“They have invariably increased the judgment sum to N330 million. My Lord, it is high time counsel were warned so that they will stop to deceive the court. This is deliberate. This is deliberate,” he decried.

The policeman, due to this fact, requested the panel to dismiss the petition, arguing that “If this panel allows this petition, it will affect the matter that is pending in court.

“It will open the floodgates. All matters before courts will come before the panel. We’re praying that the petition be struck out,” he submitted.

The petitioner’s counsel, Olalekan Ghazali, nevertheless, objected to the views of the police counsel and contended, amongst others, that Paschal had a proper to be heard.

(FILE) Members of the Lagos State Judicial Panel of Inquiry and Restitution at a sitting on November 28, 2020.

 

A Judicial Trap

In a bench ruling, the chairman of the panel, Justice Doris Okuwobi, upheld Ebosereme’s argument that the petition was an abuse of course of.

“On the reply of the petitioner’s counsel that it is within the petitioner’s right… to present its petition, this panel must subject itself to the jurisdiction of the appellate court and must not attempt to take any proceedings which will overreach the decision of the appellate court.

“The fact that there is a pending appeal at the Supreme Court against IGP vs Bruno … & Anor, is clearly established by the notice of appeal dated 7th October 2020. There is also an application in court for the setting aside of the garnishee order made by Aikawa J of the Federal High Court,” she stated.

Justice Okuwobi added, “For the petitioner in his petition to seek redress for restitution against police brutality and enforcement of the judgment sum in the petitioner’s favour by requesting for enforcement of N300m, is grave abuse of process of the court.

“The enrolled judgment of the Court of Appeal reducing the judgment to N30 million is crystal clear and the petitioner’s counsel (Olukoya Ogungbeje Esq) was before the Court of Appeal when the judgment was delivered.

“To now (petition) for enforcement of N300 million is a grave misrepresentation and non-disclosure of the actual state of affairs with the case. The notice of appeal to the Supreme Court was endorsed in the first place by… Olukoya Ogungbeje Esq. I find that the … documentary evidence before the court is so glaring that the process before the court is one that constitutes serious abuse.”

The chairman held that the panel can’t be referred to as upon to safe obedience to a judgment that has been different by the enchantment court docket and topic to an extra enchantment to the Supreme Court.

According to her, the petition lacks advantage and is meant to place the panel on a collision course with proceedings pending earlier than appellate courts.

“We will not fall into this judicial trap. The petition is incompetent, lacking in merit, and accordingly hereby dismissed for being an abuse of process of the court,” Justice Okuwobi dominated.

Click to comment

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *